Evangelicalism and Politics


We cannot scripturally defend those who are wrong because we believe their political party is on our side..

The following is from a op-ed by Cal Thomas.

This being the 500th anniversary of the Protestant Reformation, politically active Christians would do well to read deeper than the 95 Theses Martin Luther supposedly “nailed” to that church in Wittenberg, Germany, in 1517. Luther was distressed about the corruption that had overtaken the Roman Catholic Church.

In an essay for Modern Age Journal, titled “Beyond the Reformation of Politics,” Alec Ryre, professor of Christianity at England’s Durham University, writes that Luther believed governments were ordained by God to restrain sinners and little else. Real transformation of individuals and thus societies, he reasoned, could be achieved only by a changed heart, which is the work of the church, not government.

“In Luther’s view,” writes Ryre, “God permits these scoundrels to rule because ‘the world is too wicked, and does not deserve to have many wise and upright princes.’ Anticipating (James) Madison, Luther argued that it is only because of human sin that God had instituted government at all, in order to make some limited semblance of peace and order possible.”

That is the antithesis of the theology and political activism of many modern evangelicals, who seem to prefer access to temporal power more than faithfulness to a kingdom and King not of this world.

Ryre continues: “(Luther’s) point, deeply counterintuitive to most modern sensibilities, is that government is not very important. It is necessary in a humdrum way for as long as this passing world endures, but Christians should not pay much attention to it. Their hearts should be set instead on the kingdom of Christ, where there is no law, and no coercion, and which is not passing away.”

There is an unstated conceit among some evangelicals that God is only at work when a Republican is elected, even a Republican who does not share their view of Jesus, or practice what He taught. It is the ultimate compromise, which leads to the corruption and dilution of a message more powerful than what government and politics offer.

German Protestantism made its own Faustian bargain in the 1930s. Theologian Gerhard Kittel joined with other Protestant leaders in a proclamation declaring Adolf Hitler “A call of God.” More like a call of Satan. Dietrich Bonhoeffer was the better example of a serious believer who confronted the Nazis with the power and truth of that other kingdom and was martyred for it.

Henry VIII provides another cautionary tale when it comes to fusing faith with politics. Here’s Ryre’s indictment: “Henry was no Protestant, but most English Protestants were willing to swallow their principles for the sake of an alliance with him…”

Principles are still being swallowed today in exchange for a false sense of influence and power.

In the Book of Revelation, Jesus says about the church at Ephesus, which had been strongly influenced by the Emperor’s cult and worship of the Greek goddess Artemis: “You have left your first love,” meaning Himself. (Rev 2:4)

For too many modern Protestants, politics has become a cult and their “Artemis.” They are forgetting their first love, the consequences of which can be found in history, dating back to Israel’s King David, who warned, “Do not put your trust in princes, in human beings, who cannot save.” (Psalm 146:3)

9 thoughts on “Evangelicalism and Politics

      1. Sadly the church has given government the responsibility of both caring for those who are in need and creating laws that restrict those who are not in line with our beliefs – I believe God wants (as alluded to in your post) people to be transformed not socially engineered

        Liked by 1 person

  1. Cliff

    It would be impossible for me to agree more with this. I am sorely distressed by big ball of religion and politics so many Christians have gotten rolled up in. I truly believe Satan loves it that way, because then we are distracted from what is our only true purpose…the spread of the glorious Gospel of Jesus Christ.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. When I read these words, “Luther believed governments were ordained by God to restrain sinners and little else. Real transformation of individuals and thus societies, he reasoned, could be achieved only by a changed heart, which is the work of the church, not government.”, it is difficult for me to describe the release I felt, and peace.
      Leading up to the election in 2016 and even beyond that I found myself constantly agitated


    2. Sorry for the two parts I found myself constantly agitated and worried about the state of our government.
      My wife who carries most of the wisdom in our relationship LOL notice this and said you need to stop reading Fox News.
      I think you were right Satan does love love it when we’re focused on the wrong things. Assigning government it’s proper place, and leaving everything else up to God working through us as a much better place and frame of mine to be.


      1. I am very glad that, personally, I have never gotten to sidetracked by it all. I have been blessed in that sense. I mean, I am concerned about the state of our government, but not consumed by it. I do get agitated still, though, by folks who honestly think, “if we only had a Christian in the White House all would be well.” That is patently absurd. Luther nailed that one.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s